CANBERRA SEC 4E5NA Social Studies Prelim 2 Answer Scheme

________________________________________________________________________________________________ Canberra Secondary School Social Studies 2019 Preliminary Examination Secondary 4 Express/5NA Sec 4E/5NA 2019 Social Studies Prelim 2 Answer Scheme Study Source A. a. What is the message of the cartoon? Explain your answer. [5] Level Descriptors Marks L1 Describing the source/ provenance e.g. Source A is a A cartoonist’s depiction of how US President Donald Trump views immigrants. 1m L2 Invalid interpretation, unsupported/supported Award 2m for 1 sub-message unsupported. 3m one main message unsupported. e.g. The message of the cartoon is that the Trump government sees immigrants as causing problems for America. 2-3m L3 Main message, support Award 4 m for 1 sub message supported. e.g. The message of the cartoon is that Trump does not welcome immigrants to America. Source A shows US President Donald Trump commenting that the immigrants are ‘A Horde of Honduran rapists, drug dealers, and terrorists is marching toward our border’ . In the next picture, Trump is seen standing away from the immigrants. This suggests that Trump does see immigrants as being negative for the society and does not see America benefitting from the entry of such immigrants. 4m L4 Main message supported with verb and audience e.g. The message of the cartoon is to convince Americans that Trump does not welcome immigrants to America. Source A shows US President Donald Trump commenting that the immigrants are ‘A Horde of Honduran rapists, drug dealers, and terrorists is marching toward our border’. In the next pictures, Trump is seen standing away from the immigrants. This suggests that Trump does see immigrants as being negative for the society and does not see America benefitting fr om the entry of such immigrants. As such, America does not welcome such immigrants. 5m

________________________________________________________________________________________________ Canberra Secondary School Social Studies 2019 Preliminary Examination Secondary 4 Express/5NA b. Study Sources B and C. Do you think Source B agrees with Source C? Explain your answer. [6m] Level Descriptors Marks L1 Similarity or Difference, based on Provenance/ Topic Difference e.g. Source B does not agree with Source C as Source B is a written source but Source C is a cartoon. 1m L2 False Match/ No Match e.g. Source B does not agree with Source C as Source B tells me that immigrants are welcome in USA but Source C does not. 2m L3 Similarity or difference in content unsupported, i.e. must be valid matches Award 3m for Similarity or difference in content, unsupported. Award 4m for Similarity AND difference in content, un