CHRIST CHURCH 4E5N SS Prelims 2019 ANS

Section A (Source-Based Case Study) Question 1 is compulsory for all candidates. 1. (a) Study Source A. Why do you think the photo was created? Explain your answer. [5] Level Descriptor Marks L1 Describes with no inference. The photo was created to show the diversity in China. 1 L2 Inference(s), unsupported The photo was created because it wants to tell me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [S] 2 L3 Inference, supported by details from Source A and explanation. Award 3m for one inference support by details from Source A. Award 4m for a more developed explanation. The photo was created because it wants to tell me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [S] Source A shows many different ethnic groups dressed in their different ethnic costumes welcoming people to China. [Ev] OR The photo was created to tell me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity [S] because there are different cultural groups with unique difference s but they are all a ble to come together to achieve a common goal . Despite being from different cultural 3 – 4

2 CHR 2019 / HUMANITIES (SOCIAL STUDIES) 2272/01 & 2273/01 backgrounds, they still have a common sense of belonging and national identity to China. [Ex] Source A shows many different ethnic groups dressed in their different ethnic costumes welcoming people to China. [Ev] L4 Purpose of source, supported The photo was created because it wants to convince [V] the viewers of the website [A] that East Asian countries celebrate diversity and that it is very culturally exciting [M] so that the viewers will be more enticed to visit China as tourists. [I] Source A shows many different ethnic groups dressed in their different ethnic costumes welcoming people to China. [Ev] 5 1. (b) Study Source B and Source C. In what ways do the sources disa gree with each other? Explain your answer. [6] Level Descriptor Marks L1 Comparisons based on Source Type / Provenance / Topic. Source B disagrees with Source C as Source B talks only about Islam while Source C talks about all the different cultures in Asia. 1 L2 Comparison(s), unsupported / sup ported by details from Source B or C. Award 2m for one unsupported comparison. Award 3m for one comparison supported by details from one source. Award 3m for two unsupported comparisons. Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of whether East Asia celebrates diversity. 2 – 3

3 CHR 2019 / HUMANITIES (SOCIAL STUDIES) 2272/01 & 2273/01 Source B tells me that East Asian countries do not celebrate diversity while Source C tells me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [CS] AND / OR Source B and C di sagree with each other in terms of whether East Asia celebrates diversity. Source B tells me that East Asian countries do not celebrate diversity while Source C tells me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [CS] Source B says “ The Chinese gover nment's plan to make Islam compatible with Chinese culture and society has attracted widespread criticism.” [Ev – B] AND / OR Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of whether East Asia celebrates diversity. Source B tells me that East Asian countries do not celebrate diversity while Source C tells me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [CS] Source C says “ Dazzling dance steps and music from different corners of Asia livened up the National Stadium in Beijing Wednesday evening as a grand carnival was held to celebrat e the diversity of Asian civilisations.” [Ev – C] AND / OR Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of the policies used by the Chinese government to manage diversity. Source B tells me that the policies us ed is very harsh and unwelcoming but Source B tells me that the policies used is not harsh and welcoming. [CS] AND / OR

4 CHR 2019 / HUMANITIES (SOCIAL STUDIES) 2272/01 & 2273/01 Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of the policies used by the Chinese government to manage diversity. Source B tells me that the policies used is very harsh and unwelcoming but Source B tells me that the policies used is not harsh and welcoming. [CS] Source B says “O n Sunday, Chinese autho rities announced their plan to sinicise* Islam through a five-year plan.” [Ev – B] AND / OR Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of the policies used by the Chinese government to manage diversity. Source B tells me that the policies used is very harsh and unwelcoming but Source B tells me that the policies used is not harsh and welcoming. [CS] Source C says “ Chinese people sincerely hope that Asian countries will help each other and work closely together to advance with the rest of the world, he said.” [Ev – C] L3 Comparison(s), supported by details from Source B and C and explanations. Award 4m for one comparison supported by details from Source B and C. Award 1 more mark for a more developed answer. Award 5m for two comparisons supported by details from Source B and C. Source B and C disagree with each oth er in terms of whether East Asia celebrates diversity. Source B tells me that East Asian countries do not celebrate diversity while Source C tells me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [CS] Source B says “ The Chinese government's plan to make Islam compatible with Chinese culture and society has attracted widespread criticism.” [Ev – B] While Source C says “ Dazzling dance steps and music from different corners of Asia livened up the National Stadium in Beijing Wednesday evening as a grand carnival was held to celebrat e the diversity of Asian civilisations.” [Ev – C] 4 – 5

5 CHR 2019 / HUMANITIES (SOCIAL STUDIES) 2272/01 & 2273/01 AND / OR Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of whether East Asia celebrates diversity. Source B tells me that East Asian countries do not celebrate diversity because China is forcing minority groups adopt their own practices and beliefs. While Source C tells me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity because the leaders of China are able to appreciate the differences the different cultures in Asia bring to society. [CS and Ex] Source B says “ The Chinese government's plan to make Islam compatible with Chinese culture and society has attracted widespread criticism.” [Ev – B] While Source C says “ Dazzling dance steps and music from different corners of Asia live ned up the National Stadium in Beijing Wednesday evening as a grand carnival was held to celebrat e the diversity of Asian civilisations.” [Ev – C] AND / OR Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of the policies used by the Chinese government to manage diversity. Source B tells me that the policies used is very harsh and unwelcoming but Source B tells me that the policies used is not harsh and welcoming. [CS] Source B says “O n Sunday, Chinese autho rities announced their plan to sinicis e* Islam through a five -year plan. ” [Ev – B] While Source C says “ Chinese people sincerely hope that Asian countries will help each other and work closely together to advance with the rest of the world, he said.” [Ev – C] AND / OR Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of the policies used by the Chinese government to manage diversity. Source B tells me that the policies used is very harsh and unwelcoming because the Chinese authorities do not

6 CHR 2019 / HUMANITIES (SOCIAL STUDIES) 2272/01 & 2273/01 accommodate differences in minority ethnic groups and fo rce them to conform to the majority but Source C tells me that the policies used is not harsh and welcoming because China’s leaders believe that different groups are able to uniquely support and contribute to Asia in their different ways. [CS and Ex] Source B says “O n Sunday, Chin