christchurch prelim ans

Section A (Source-Based Case Study) Question 1 is compulsory for all candidates. 1. (a) Study Source A. Why do you think the photo was created? Explain your answer. [5] Level Descriptor Marks L1 Describes with no inference. The photo was created to show the diversity in China. 1 L2 Inference(s), unsupported The photo was created because it wants to tell me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [S] 2 L3 Inference, supported by details from Source A and explanation. Award 3m for one inference support by details from Source A. Award 4m for a more developed explanation. The photo was created because it wants to tell me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [S] Source A shows many different ethnic groups dressed in their different ethnic costumes welcoming people to China. [Ev] OR The photo was created to tell me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity [S] because there are different cultural groups with unique differences but they are all able to come together to achieve a common goal. Despite being from different cultural 3 – 4

2 CHR 2019 / HUMANITIES (SOCIAL STUDIES) 2272/01 & 2273/01 backgrounds, they still have a common sense of belonging and national identity to China. [Ex] Source A shows many different ethnic groups dressed in their different ethnic costumes welcoming people to China. [Ev] L4 Purpose of source, supported The photo was created because it wants to convince [V] the viewers of the website [A] that East Asian countries celebrate diversity and that it is very culturally exciting [M] so that the viewers will be more enticed to visit China as tourists. [I] Source A shows many different ethnic groups dressed in their different ethnic costumes welcoming people to China. [Ev] 5 1. (b) Study Source B and Source C. In what ways do the sources disagree with each other? Explain your answer. [6] Level Descriptor Marks L1 Comparisons based on Source Type / Provenance / Topic. Source B disagrees with Source C as Source B talks only about Islam while Source C talks about all the different cultures in Asia. 1 L2 Comparison(s), unsupported / supported by details from Source B or C. Award 2m for one unsupported comparison. Award 3m for one comparison supported by details from one source. Award 3m for two unsupported comparisons. Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of whether East Asia celebrates diversity. 2 – 3

3 CHR 2019 / HUMANITIES (SOCIAL STUDIES) 2272/01 & 2273/01 Source B tells me that East Asian countries do not celebrate diversity while Source C tells me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [CS] AND / OR Source B and C disagree with each other in terms of whether East Asia celebrates diversity. Source B tells me that East Asian countries do not celebrate diversity while Source C tells me that East Asian countries celebrate diversity. [CS] Source