2026 TJC H2 Econs P1 Prelim ANS
Uploaded by ohnoe · 7 November 2026
TJC 2026 prelim set
- P1 QP
- 2026 TJC H2 Econs P1 Prelim ANSyou're here
- P2 QP
- P2 MSanswers
Preview
Text from the first pages2026 TJC H2 Economics Prelim CSQ Suggested Answers H2 Question 1: Changes in the market for semiconductors Suggested Answers (a) With reference to Table 1 and Extract 1, (i) state the overall trend in the average selling price of NAND flash memory and calculate its percentage change between 2020 and 2025 (estimate). [2] ● The average selling price of NAND flash memory shows an overall increasing trend between 2020 and 2025 (estimate). [1m] ● Percentage change = x 100 = 37.4% (3 s.f.)[1m] $0 . 125 − $0 . 091 $0 . 091 Markers’ Comments ● ‘Upward’ trend with no mention of overall average selling price of NAND flash memory ‘increasing’ will not be awarded. Students should be clear when stating the overall trend. ● Students should be careful with the calculation following the formula when calculating percentage change (final - initial/ initial * 100%) and round off correctly . An approximation of the value will not be awarded the mark. (ii) using demand and supply analysis, explain the likely effects of the rise in AI on the change in the price of NAND flash memory between 2020 and 2025 (estimate). [4] Trigger: Rise in AI tech ● From extract 1, “The rapid growth of AI technologies has significantly increased demand for electronic products”. This shows that rise in AI resulted in demand for electronic products increase and hence the derived demand for NAND flash memory as a factor of production for electronic products increased [1m] ● Also, “major industry players… diverted silicon wafer capacity away from NAND flash memory production and towards the production of AI accelerators”. This means that NAND flash memory and AI accelerators, both being FOPs for electronic products, are in competitive supply (shared silicon wafer input). The supply of NAND flash memory chips decreased [1m] ● Market adjustment process – existing price, there is a shortage leading to upward pressure on prices. Therefore, DD ↑ + SS↓ led to the overall price increase as shown in table 1. [2m] (b) Using Figure 1, identify and explain the type of market structure that the NAND flash memory market operates in. [2] ● Oligopoly [1m] ● Figure 1 shows that the market is dominated by a small number of large firms – the top 5 vendors (Samsung, SK Group, Kioxia, Micron, and Western Digital) collectively hold approximately 95.8% of global market share, with the remaining 4.2% split among all other producers
indicating high market concentration characteristic of an oligopoly. [1m] (c) With reference to Extract 3, explain whether the knowledge generated through Research and Development (R&D) exhibits the characteristics of a public good. [4] ● A public good possesses two key characteristics: non-excludability (impossible or impractical to prevent non-payers from benefiting once the good/service has been provided) and non-rivalry (one person's use does not reduce availability to others) 1
2026 TJC H2 Economics Prelim CSQ Suggested Answers Knowledge generated through R&D exhibits the characteristics of a public good ● From Extract 3, “scientific knowledge is non-rival, multiple firms and sectors can draw on the same insights simultaneously”, this shows that when one semiconductor firm taps on the knowledge generated through R&D, it does not leave less knowledge in terms of quantity or quality for another firm. Hence, knowledge generated from R&D can be considered as non-rivalry in consumption. ● Also from Extract 3, “Once findings are published in journals or embodied by mobile researchers, they become difficult to contain: no single firm can exclude others from learning from them.”, this shows that once R&D knowledge is published or carried by mobile researchers to other firms, the originating firm has no technical or legal means of preventing rival firms from accessing and benefiting from it without payment, meaning knowledge generated from R&D is non-excludable. Knowledge generated through R&D may not exhibit the characteristics of a public good ● From extract 3, “private investment in applied research…. capturing commercial returns through patents and trade secrets, which legally exclude competitors” This shows that knowledge from R&D in the form of private investment in applied research is excludable through patents and trade secrets. ● It is possible to exclude competitors (non-payers) from enjoying the benefits of such private research. Although knowledge is typically classified as a non-rivalrous good, R&D-derived outputs such as patents can exhibit a form of rivalry in use, since their economic value is closely tied to timing and market conditions. ● A firm that acquires the rights to a patent later may earn substantially less revenue from it than the original user did as the market might be saturated. This means that when one user consumes the good (knowledge gain from R&D to produce a product) it will diminish the benefits to the next user that is consuming the good, contradicting the non-rivalry characteristic of a public good. Hence, it is a private good rather than a public good. Max 3m if answer is one-sided (addresses only basic OR applied research, not both). (d) Discuss the extent to which the 'supply discipline' mentioned in Extract 2 explains why firms in the NAND flash memory industry can make and retain large profits. [8] Question Interpretation Command Discuss the extent to which... explains why... Balanced analysis of how much "supply discipline" (tacit collusion) explains large and retained profits, alongside other factors. Clear, reasoned conclusion on its relative significance. Content Supply discipline, make and retain large profits Tacit collusion as collective monopolist (restrict output) PED<1 → restriction raises TR (making profit); reinvestment into BTE — R&D/patents, control of wafer supply (retaining profit); risk of cheating/no reinvestment eroding profit; possible EOS loss (weak
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
