HCI 2026 H1 Geog Prelim Ans
Uploaded by Grassy155 · 16 November 2026
Preview
Text from the first pages2026 HCI Prelim H1 Geography ANSWERS 1 A group of four Geography students in Singapore investigated the effectiveness of sheltered walkways as an adaptation strategy for residents coping with rising temperatures. They focused on a route between an HDB residential block next to their school and a nearby Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) station. The students noted that while a sheltered walkway existed, it was incomplete as the walkway did not cover the entire route to the MRT station. Instead of walking to the MRT station from their homes, many residents continued to take a bus to the MRT station. The students came up with the following geographical question for their fieldwork: “Why do residents take a bus to the MRT train station instead of using the walkway?” They divided themselves into two pairs, and conducted their fieldwork from 4 to 6 pm, every Wednesday in May as it was their designated home -based learning (HBL) day. Each day, one pair would count the number of residents using the sheltered walkway to get to the MRT station, while another pair would count the number of residents alight ing from the bus at the MRT station. The students also noted the weather and traffic conditions. In addition, they used a digital temperature sensor to measure the ambient temperature at seven selected points along the route. They also noted the features and details of the immediate surroundings at each point. They did this at 2 pm on a sunny Thursday afternoon in June. Resource 1A is a map showing the walking route and the selected temperature measurement points. Resource 1B shows a photograph of a section along the route between Measuring Points 6 and 7. Resource 2 shows the number of residents using the route in the month of May, together with the prevailing weather and traffic conditions on each day. Resource 3A shows the information collected at each selected point along the route in June. Resource 3B shows a picture of the digital temperature sensor. (a) Explain why the students’ question is appropriate for their investigation. [3] Award 1 mark for each explanation on why the students’ question is appropriate for their investigation, to a maximum of 3 marks. Point marked • The research question is at a suitable scale and is manageable for a group of four students because: the length of the route (measuring about 500 metres between the MRT station and the school) [1] OR the students have chosen to focus solely on a particular stakeholder group (residents) [1]. • The items in the research question are measurable, especially since the students are able to count the number of residents who prefer to walk and take the MRT [1]. • The research question is clearly defined, as seen from the: o clear identification of a stakeholder group (residents) that the investigation will focus on [1] OR o clear indication of the specific issue being investigated (i.e. that residents are continuing to take the bus instead of walking to the MRT station) [1].
2 (b) With reference to Resources 1A and 1B, explain how students can minimise potential risks when conducting their fieldwork along the walkway between their school and the MRT train station. [4] Point marked Award 1 mark for each explanation of how students can minimise potential risks when conducting their fieldwork along the route between their school and the MRT train station, to a maximum of 4 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation, where applicable. Possible responses include: • Students should take care to give way to pedestrians, so as to ensure personal safety and minimise the occurrence of accidents [1]. For instance, students should take care not to bump into young children and elderly or obstruct those who are using Personal Mobility Aids (PMAs) [+1]. • Students should obey traffic signs and look out for traffic when crossing the roads at various junctions along the route [1]. This is to minimise the occurrences of accidents [1]. • Students should ensure that good walking shoes are worn, to minimise slipping/tripping [1]. This is especially so when walking on uneven and vegetated terrain beside the pavements/ avoiding tripping and falling into canal [+1]. • Students should ensure that they always work in pairs or in a group so that they can look out for one another’s safety [1]. • Hydration/ sunscreen to mitigate heat stress [1] (c) Suggest reasons for the number of residents walking to the MRT train station shown in Resource 2 . [4] Point marked. Award 1 mark for each explanation of how weather conditions may have influenced the number of students using the sheltered walkway, to a maximum of 2 marks. Award 1 mark for each explanation of how traffic conditions may have influenced the number of students using the sheltered walkway, to a maximum of 2 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation, where applicable. Possible responses include: • The occurrence of heavy rain on 3 May likely resulted in fewer residents using the walkway to get to the MRT station because parts of the walkway are not covered/sheltered [1]. This may have led residents to take the bus instead to stay as dry as possible [+1] or avoid the hassle of bringing/ forgetting to bring an umbrella [+1] • Very heavy traffic congestion due to roadworks on 17 May could have resulted in more residents using the walkway to get to the MRT station because bus services and private cars may have been delayed [1]. As a result of this, it may have been faster for th e residents to walk and take the MRT instead [+1]. • Cooling weather on a cloudy day – residents may not mind saving bus fare/ walking to get some exercise [1] (d) With reference to Resources 1A, 1B, and 3A, explain why the students’ selection of the 7 temperature measurement points is appropriate. [5] Point marked. Award 1 mark for each explanation of why the students’ selection of the 7 temperature measurement points is appropriate, to a maximum of 5 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation, where applicable. Possible responses include: • The sample size (i.e. number of measurement points) is manageable for a group of 4 students to complete in one afternoon [1]. • Measurement points are sufficiently far apart from one another along the route, which improves the representativeness of the sample [1].
3 • Measurement points are differentiated by their coverage from the sheltered walkway, which is relevant to the students’ interest in finding out the effectiveness of sheltered walkways [1]. For example, 5 of the measurement points are covered by the sheltered walkway, and 2 of them are not covered [+1]. • Measurement points are also differentiated by their surrounding features, which helps students recognise the possible influence of other factors on the walkability of the walkway [1]. For example, the surrounding features observed by the students included a canal, varying densities of planted trees, and varying types of vegetation [+1]. (e) With reference to Resources 3A and 3B, explain how the students can ensure the reliability of the ambient temperature data they collected. [4] Point marked. Award 1 mark for each explanation of how the students can ensure the reliability of the ambient temperature data they had collected, to a maximum of 6 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation, where applicable. Possible responses include: • Students can repeat the measurements three times and take an average reading at each measurement point [1]. • Students can hold the digital temperature sensor consistently at the same
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
