JPJC 2026 H1 Geog Prelim Ans
Uploaded by Grassy155 · 16 November 2026
Preview
Text from the first pagesH1 Geography Prelim Suggested Answers Cluster 2: Fieldwork 1 (a) Suggest how the students’ hypothesis can be improved. [3] Award 1 mark for each suggestion on how the hypothesis can be improved, to a maximum of 3 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each suggestion, where applicable. Explanation [1m] and Further Development [+1m] • A suitable spatial scope i.e. (Bukit Panjang) would improve the hypothesis as the students had collected data in one neighbourhood in Singapore. [1m] • Precise age-group definitions would improve the hypothesis because “youths” and “other age groups” are vague, so exact numerical age ranges should be stated to create clear, mutually exclusive independent-variable categories. [1m] • Furthermore, precise age -group definitions would enable all six students to classify participants consistently across the three return points, reducing observer variation and improving the reliability of comparisons between age groups. [+1m]
2 (b) With reference to Resources 1A and 1B, explain one strength and one weakness of the selected return points. [4] Award 1 mark for each explanation on the strength or weakness, to a maximum of 4 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation of strength or weakness, where applicable. Award maximum of 2 marks for either strengths or weaknesses only. Explanation [1m] and Further Development [+1m] • The land-use diversity of the selected return points is a strength because Resources 1A and 1B show sites at a hawker centre and market, a FairPrice supermarket outlet and an HDB void deck, allowing participation to be studied across contrasting everyday settings. [1m] • For example, Return Point X at Bukit Panjang Hawker Centre and Market may capture diners and market visitors, while Return Point Y at FairPrice captures shoppers, possibly increasing the range of age groups included in the observations. [+1m] • The selected return points are located in areas with high pedestrian footfall , such as Bukit Panjang Hawker Centre and Market and FairPrice supermarket, increasing the likelihood of observing a larger number of potential participants within the data-collection period. [1m] • This can increase the sample size and reliability of the observations , as more people are exposed to the return points, reducing the likelihood that findings are based on only a small number of users. [+1m]
3 (c) Suggest how students could minimise the impact of their investigation at the three return points. [4] Award 1 mark for each suggestion on how students could minimise the impact of their investigation, to a maximum of 4 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each suggestion, where applicable. Explanation [1m] and Further Development [+1m] • Avoiding obstruction to pedestrian movement would minimise the investigation’s impact because students should stand beside, rather than directly in front of, return machines, entrances and walkways, preventing congestion and allowing users to move safely. [1m] • For example, at Return Point Y, students should approach respondents only after they have returned their containers and move away from the supermarket shelves to avoid inconveniencing customers or disrupting business operations. [+1m] • Minimising disturbance to the public would reduce the investigation’s social impact because students should conduct observations quietly and administer questionnaires only to willing participants without interrupting shopping, dining or other daily activities. [1m] • Leaving the sites clean would minimise the investigation’s environmental impact because students should collect all worksheets, stationery and personal waste after data collection instead of leaving litter that could reduce the cleanliness of public spaces. [1m]
4 (d) Describe how the data shown in Resource 2 may be represented. [4] Award 1 mark for each description on how the data may be represented to a maximum of 4 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each suggestion, where applicable. Graph type Description [1m] and Further Development [+1m] Compound bar graph • A compound bar graph could place Return Points X, Y and Z on the horizontal axis, while the vertical axis shows the number of people using a scale from zero to at least 36. [1m] • Each compound bar should represent the total number of people recorded at its return point, with bar heights of 36 at X, 28 at Y and 24 at Z. [+1m] • Each bar should be subdivided into youth and non-youth sections, using values of 18 and 18 at X, 7 and 21 at Y, and 10 and 14 at Z. [+1m] • Contrasting shading and a clear legend, title and axis labels should distinguish youths from non-youths, allowing both the total number and youth composition at each return point to be compared. [+1m]
5 (e) Explain how the questionnaire shown in Resource 3 may be improved. [5] Award 1 mark for each explanation on how the questionnaire may be improved, to a maximum of 5 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation, where applicable. Explanation [1m] and Further Development [+1m] • The age-group classification in Resource 3 should be made exhaustive and mutually exclusive because “0–7 years”, “10–16 years”, “20–25 years” and “Above 25 years” omit people aged 8–9 and 17–19, preventing complete and accurate data collection. [1m] • For example, the questionnaire could use continuous categories such as 0–9, 10–19, 20–29 and 30 years or above, ensuring every respondent can be classified consistently for comparison. [+1m] • The respondent coverage should be widened because the questionnaires were administered only to youths, however the hypothesis compares youths’ participation with that of other age groups, producing an unrepresentative sample for testing the stated relationship. [1m] • For example, at all three Bukit Panjang return points, students should administer the same questionnaire to youths and adults from each identified age group, allowing direct comparison of their reported participation rates. [+1m] • The question validity of Resource 3 should be improved because Q1 asks “Which age group do you think is more likely to use the Return Points?”, measuring respondents’ perceptions rather than their actual recycling behaviour. [1m] • For example, respondents at the Bukit Panjang return points could instead be asked how many times they personally returned beverage containers during the previous month, generating measurable evidence directly linked to participation. [+1m]
6 (f) Evaluate the data collection methods for this investigation. [10] Possible approaches: Candidates could evaluate the investigation by reviewing the methods used to collect data and the data presented in Resources 1A, 1B, 2 and 3. Candidates could review the counting procedure at each return point and/or assess all three sites collectively. Evaluation could include whether collecting data concurrently from 08:00 to 11:00 on one Friday morning improved comparability, whether the three student groups applied consistent age-group classifications, and whether differences between observers affected the accuracy and reliability of the co
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
