CJC 2026 H1 Geog Prelim Ans
Uploaded by Grassy155 · 16 November 2026
Preview
Text from the first pagesCatholic Junior College JC2 Preliminary Examination Higher 1 GEOGRAPHY 8834/01 Paper 1 28 August 2026 3 hours Additional Materials: Insert READ THESE INSTRUCTIONS FIRST An Answer Booklet will be provided with this question paper. You should follow the instructions on the front cover of the answer booklet. If you need additional answer paper, ask the invigilator for a continuation booklet. Answer Question 1 in Section A. Answer both questions in Section B. Answer two questions in Section C. The number of marks is given in brackets [ ] at the end of each question or part question. This document consists of 4 printed pages.
2 Section A Cluster 2 Fieldwork 1 A group of four students carried out fieldwork to investigate whether Melbourne Central Business District (CBD) supports the well -being of the elderly . Their investigation focused on transportation access to social amenities. Their hypothesis was: The quality and accessibility of Melbourne CBD's public transport network positively influence the social wellbeing of elderly people. The students allocated 3 hours for their investigation on an afternoon. The students visited Southern Cross Station to observe and interview elderly people. They surveyed 18 elderly Caucasian people aged 67 to 84 using a short questionnaire containing both closed and open -ended questions about their accessibility within Melbourne CBD. They also boarded a few trams to conduct observations about accessibility of public transport for elderly people. They took photographs and used a checklist to assess features such as lighting, reserved seating for the elderly , wheelchair access and space. Resource 1 is a map of Melbourne CBD. Resource 2 shows photographs of the sites that students visited to collect data . Resource 3 shows the questionnaire used by the students for the survey. Resources 4A and 4B shows selected findings from the survey and observations. (a) Explain one weakness and one strength of the students’ hypothesis. Award 1 mark for each explanation. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development. • The independent variables of quality and accessibility were clearly defined to allow for focus in the research. [1] This will allow students to manage their time well by scoping to these 2 elements. [+1] • The variables were researchable because students would be able to observe and get perception data on quality and accessibility. [1] The Melbourne CBD is also open so students can access the sites to collect data. [+1] • The public transport network of Melbourne CBD could be too big for the students to investigate. [1] This is also not possible for 4 students to cover the entire CBD in 3 hours. [+1] • The students wanted to investigate quality and accessibility which would be 2 dimensions and therefore too large a scope for students to complete in one afternoon. [1] AO1 [4] (b) With reference to Resource 2, explain the possible risks the students might face during the investigation. [3]
3 Award 1 mark for each explanation. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development. • Students might be at risk of getting knocked down by vehicles as the area looked to be a large road with possibility of dense traffic. [1] • Students might face exhaustion at the station where there are hardly any seats for them to rest during the research. [1] • The area outside the station looks unsheltered and students are at risk of heat injury. [1] • Students might get injured via collision with people on wheelchairs when they stand close to the small entrance of trams. [1] They might also be at risk if verbal conflict should people feel that they are blocking the way at the entrance of the tram. [+1] AO1 (c) With reference to Resource 2, explain how the students could address the ethical issues in their investigation. Award 1 mark for each explanation. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development. • Students should ensure that they do not block the way of the wheelchair users, by standing further away from the entrances. [1] • They should also blur the faces of people to ensure anonymity when they do their observations and take photographs. [1] • They should also approach people who did not look like they were in a rush at the station to avoid making them miss their trains or trams. [1] • They should clarify their roles as researchers and not lead people into thinking that they can do something about the accessibility for the elderly. [1] • They can bring their litter with them as there did not seem to be any bins in the vicinity, to avoid dirtying the station. [1] AO1 [4] (d) With reference to Resource 3, explain the strengths and limitations of the questionnaire in helping the students collect accurate data. Award 1 mark for each explanation. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development. • There is sufficient range in the options given, to allow for extent of perceptions e.g. 4-point scale. [1] • Having specific questions related to access to medical supplies, work, food, recreation allowed for students to identify which areas were accessible or not, rather than grouping all under social well- being. [1] • Open-ended question allowed for specific location to identify the specific areas which could be accessible. [1] • However, the lack of criteria for the 4 -point scale may lead to subjectivity in interpreting “very convenient” vs “convenient”. [1] [5]
4 • Double-barrelled question in Q9 means that students are unable to accurately assess accessibility to either recreation or doctor visits. [1] • “Food supplies” is unclear because it can mean cooked food or groceries. [1] AO2 (e) Explain how the data in Resource 4B may be represented using a graph. Award 1 mark for each explanation. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development. • Present in a compound bar chart, with each segment of the compound bar representing various options. [1] • X-axis to be the questions that allow for comparison across the questions. [1] • Y-axis to be the percentage of responses. [1] • Segments to be coloured differently to allow for comparison within the question. [1] AO2 [4] (f) The students concluded that transportation in Melbourne CBD supported the social well-being of the elderly. Evaluate the validity of the students’ conclusion. Possible responses Students can evaluate the validity using the criteria of (1) comprehensiveness and relevance of the data, (2) accuracy, (3) reliability of the data. Comprehensiveness: The data was collected from student observations and corroboration with elderly perception, so this was a reasonable research. The data was also particularly relevant as lighting, seating and wheelchair access would have been necessary for a large proportion of the elderly. The access to food, medical supplies and doctor would have been key concerns of the elderly, seeing that they tended to require specialised food or medication to suit their needs. Reliability: The students also surveyed a good range of ages within this age group, allowing for seniors with different needs to be represented (84 years old vs 67 years old), seeing that with age, more specific needs and vulnerabilities are had. Accuracy: However, the data was somewhat inaccurate given the lack of specificity of the comments given for lighting, which was poor to good, [10]
5 and could be subjective given that this was based on student assessment rather than real needs by the elderly. Relevance: In addition, majority of the respondents gave negative responses (very inconvenient and inconvenient) about the convenience to questions about medical supplies and recreational
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
