RI 2026 H1 Geog Prelim Ans
Uploaded by Grassy155 · 16 November 2026
Preview
Text from the first pagesH1 Answers 1a) Using Resource 1, compare the two locations chosen to conduct the questionnaire survey. [4] DO NOT EXPLAIN. DO NOT give reasons. (4m) Just compare locational aspects only as seen in the MAP. Do not discuss characteristics of locations not seen on map. Eg Do not discuss how both sites will receive different visitors. This is not seen in the resource EVIDENCE and as seen from the map!!! Rationale – these reasons NOT needed in answers, but rather why the idea makes sense SIM both located within area of study 1m so most probably will receive mostly people residing in the area of study SIM Both are close to public and private housing 1m So hopefully we get a good mix of both private and public housing residents DIFF Marymount Station is close to “other land use” 1-2m So at Marymount Station, we may encounter some people from that area, but they are not residents. They r most likely workers from that area. SIM Both are located at edge / periphery of area of study 1m May also get others living outside area of study SIM Both located close to ROADS (0m) No credit!! No real reasons. These roads are not barriers to accesibility. b) With reference to Resources 2A and 2B, suggest how the students could minimise potential risks when visiting both locations. [6] Identify each risk and how to mitigate it. Risks at 2A Risks of hitting people carrying hot foods / Any other relevant ideas -Go outside of lunch hours -Go in pairs. One student keep a lookout for the main person doing the talking with respondents 1-2m Risks at 2B Risks of colliding with crowds exiting the station / Any other relevant ideas -Go to a quieter side of the station entrance to approach respondents 1-2m Dengue risks at both locations Risk of getting mosquito (RESERVED marks) Wear long sleeve tops and long trousers / using insect repellant / avoid dusk hours or night-time 1-2m Risks of wet or slippery floors. Risks of dehydration These are considered weaker ideas. Both locations are covered. 0m c) Using Resource 3, describe the strengths and limitations of the questionnaire survey. [6] DESCRIBE the strengths and limitations. DO NOT EXPLAIN in details, No long explanations needed. STRENGTHS LIMITATIONS - everything printed on one page & Q3 has 8 items only & no open-ended questions – so overall survey is short and sweet – not too inconvenient for respondent. -no unnecessary questions like asking age, gender and occupation. -survey questions in English only. So some might not understand fully. . -Q2 – asking housing type may be sensitive. Should have an option “Rather not say” to tick (1-2)
-Title and purpose of survey stated clearly. So respondents know the purpose. -The 8 items in Question 3 have a good spread of different types of dengue-prevention measures 3.1-3.4 = things done at home 3.5-3.6 = things done on an individual basis 3.7-3.8 = measures with a social element Respondents were thanked at the end of survey. -Q3 did not allow respondents to indicate frequency of conducting each measure -survey did not have any open-ended question. -Q1 is a smart way to determine relevance of respondents to target population. The alternative to verbally asking “ Do you live in Marymount-Shunfu?” can considered rude when the answer is “No” and student says “Okay. Thank you. No further questions for you. Bye”. Best to discuss this in evaluation question. -Q1 is an unscrupulous way to determine relevance of respondents to area of study. This is an ethical issue – making people complete a full survey, but ending up excluding that response. Best to discuss this in evaluation question. d) Using Resource 4, compare the results for public housing with private housing. [4] compare 4m / Must quote some stats / Reasons not needed OVERALL PATTERN / “The big picture” first ➔ Private housing always has mostly higher scores than public housing. For 7 out of 8 questions (1m) EXCEPT for one question - Q3.5 (long sleeves and long trousers) which has same scores for both public and private housing at 39% (1m) Question with the highest scores for both private and public housing - Q3.6 (used mosquito repellant) (1m) quote stats Question with the largest difference between public and private - Q3.4 55% vs 6% (1m) Some comparisons, while factually correct may not earn a credit as they may be considered weaker observation. e) Evaluate the data collection process of this fieldwork. [10] evaluate the data collection 10m -Note that data analysis (res 4) is not part of data collection process. -Everything before this is part of data collection. -If you discuss hypothesis, you must discuss about suitable data to collect, not just the suitability of the hypothesis. -Data cleaning / coding is part of data collection eg excluding invalid responses -You should avoid repeating too many ideas already given in parts (a)-(f). It just shows that you have not much else to say - this part is examine with LEVEL MARKING. Examiners are looking out for higher-order thinking. -candidates who scored higher marks (7-10marks) tend to have strong generative ideas (ie. something entirely new) Eg. Why not go knocking door-to-door to conduct survey Good or bad about current data collection What more could be done / what students failed to do -sample size is good (62 out of a population of 8000) -sample size is bad. Sample is less than 1% of population - could increase sample size to at least 100 valid responses -with more manpower (ask more friends to help) and June is a good month. June is a bad month. Many families go on overseas holidays Timing of data collection. Ensure good spread of timing. use the whole of the june school. Surveys conducted at morning / afternoon / evening and weekday/ weekends. -Extend to other months and include May and July
-only one type of primary data collected Additionally use secondary data eg govt data / NEA data especially online data - Only two locations chosen and these locations have limitations , Shunfu Market – biased towards housewives, domestic helpers and people who eat out often. People who eat at restaurants or eat at home are excluded Marymount station – exclude people who drive their own cars -include additional sampling sites. The students should include various types of location that are spread out all over area of study. This is to ensure the sample of respondents is representative of the total population. They could select a list of 10 different places that are spread all over the area of study:- 1-Market 2-train station 3-outside supermarket 4-outside community centre 5-outside GP clinic 6-at a bus stop 7-near a traffic junction 8-at a carpark 9-at a void deck of apartment block 10-outside a condominium entrance gate -Or better still, the students should consider knocking door to door / consider dropping questionnaire into letterboxes / or convert survey into an online study and display QR codes at lift lobbies or print this QR code on flyers and distribute widely so that residents can opt in and complete the online survey -more methods beyond one data collection method – survey questionnaire -after the questionnaire survey, maybe include interviews of key stakeholders eg town council workers, NEA officers, officers from Project Wolbachia (a project to release infertile male mosquitoes) These interviewees can be asked to comment on the findings from the survey -maybe conduct observational studies– eg enumerate how many people wear long sleeves and long trousers in public
2(a) Using Resource 5, describe the relationship between cities’ support of women entrepreneurship and urban liveability. [4] Award 1 mark for each description of the relationship between cities’ support of women entrepreneurship and urban liveability. Award a maximum of
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
