NJC 2026 H1 Geog Prelim Ans
Uploaded by Grassy155 · 16 November 2026
Preview
Text from the first pagesSH2 Preliminary Examinations 8834 H1 Geography Paper 1 Suggested Marking Guide Disclaimer: The Suggested Marking Guide should be treated with confidentiality, and should be used with discretion.
OFFICIAL (CLOSED) / NON-SENSITIVE National Junior College 2026 SH2 Preliminary Examinations 8834 Higher 1 Geography Marking Guide Page 2 of 20 Notes on Marking Marking Approaches a. Point marking is used for marking all sub -parts of the structured questions, except for the 10 - mark fieldwork evaluative sub-part. For point marking, the general rule is that each creditworthy response is awarded one mark. More detailed guidance is provided in the marking guide for each question. b. Generic level descriptors are used for marking: ● 10-mark fieldwork evaluative sub-part structured questions; and ● 13-mark essays. Possible approaches are provided for questions marked using generic level descriptors. They provide guidance on how the questions could be approached. The possible approaches provided are neither exhaustive nor should they be treated as a model approach to questions.
OFFICIAL (CLOSED) / NON-SENSITIVE National Junior College 2026 SH2 Preliminary Examinations 8834 Higher 1 Geography Marking Guide Page 3 of 20 Generic Level Descriptors Note: Assessment using generic level descriptors involves qualitative rather than quantitative evaluation. Judgements on the level to be awarded to an answer will be based on the principle of ‘best fit’ determined by the descriptors within each level. As a general guideline, responses deemed to have fulfilled all the descriptors within a level may be awarded the top mark in that level.
OFFICIAL (CLOSED) / NON-SENSITIVE National Junior College 2026 SH2 Preliminary Examinations 8834 Higher 1 Geography Marking Guide Page 4 of 20 Section A Cluster 2: Fieldwork Question Answer Marks 1 A group of six students in Fremantle, a port city in Australia, wanted to investigate the local community’s perceptions about sustainable healthy diet practices. Sustainable healthy diets are defined as “dietary patterns that promote all dimensions of individuals’ health and wellbeing; have low environmental pressure and impact; are accessible, affordable, safe and equitable; and are culturally acceptable” (Food an d Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) and World Health Organization (WHO), 2019). They came up with the following hypothesis for their investigation: Adults living in Fremantle with higher educational attainment (above pre-university level) are more likely to be concerned about sustainable healthy diet practices. They conducted a survey, using a questionnaire, with 100 residents aged from 18 to 75 at two sites on a Friday from 11 am to 2 pm. They used convenience sampling to select the residents for the survey. Two of the residents also agreed to participate in a face-to-face interview to elaborate on their perceptions of sustainable healthy practices. Resource 1 is a map showing the locations of Site A (Freemantle Markets) and Site B (John Curtin College of the Arts) where the survey was conducted. Resource 2 shows photographs of Sites A and B. Resource 3 shows the number of residents surveyed according to educational attainment. Resource 4 is the questionnaire used in the investigation. Resource 5 shows a summary of responses to selected questions in the questionnaire. (a) Explain why the students’ hypothesis is appropriate for the investigation. Award 1 mark for each explanation of why the hypothesis is appropriate, to a maximum of 3 marks. 3
OFFICIAL (CLOSED) / NON-SENSITIVE National Junior College 2026 SH2 Preliminary Examinations 8834 Higher 1 Geography Marking Guide Page 5 of 20 Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation, where applicable. Possible responses include: ● The hypothesis is clearly defined with a specific target group, i.e. adults living in Fremantle, for the investigation. o It also clearly defines the term “sustainable healthy diet” by adopting the FAO and WHO’s 2019 definition for the investigation. ● It is at a suitable scale as the investigation is confined within Fremantle. AO1 (b) With reference to Resources 1, 2 and 3, suggest how the students could have obtained a more representative sample of residents in Fremantle. Award 1 mark for each suggestion, to a maximum of 2 marks. Award 1 additional mark for further development of each suggestion. Possible responses include: ● Conducting the survey outside Fremantle Markets and John Curtin College of the Arts (Resources 1 & 2) introduces bias. o To obtain a more representative sample, the students could have surveyed at a wider variety of locations across different neighbourhoods in Fremantle, including residential areas, workplaces and community centres, to capture a broader cross -section of the population. ● The students should reconsider their sampling timing . Conducting the survey on a Friday between 11 am and 2 pm introduces bias. o Surveying during a weekday means the sample likely over-represents certain groups, especially those not in full-time weekday employment, while under- representing working adults. AO2 4 (c) With reference to Resource 2, suggest how the students could minimise potential risks when conducting the survey. Award 1 mark for each suggestion on how the students could minimise 4
OFFICIAL (CLOSED) / NON-SENSITIVE National Junior College 2026 SH2 Preliminary Examinations 8834 Higher 1 Geography Marking Guide Page 6 of 20 potential risks during data collection, to a maximum of 4 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each suggestion, where applicable. Possible responses include: ● First, the students should always work in pairs or trios rather than alone. This reduces personal safety risks , particularly when approaching strangers. o It ensures that there is always someone nearby in the event of an uncomfortable or threatening interaction with a member of the public. ● Second, the students should seek the necessary permission / approval before conducting the survey, i.e. from the management of Fremantle Markets and John Curtin College of the Arts, to ensure they are legally permitted to conduct surveys on or near those premises. o This minimises the risk of being asked to leave or facing legal complications mid-survey. AO1 (d) With reference to Resource 4, explain the strengths and limitations of the questionnaire used in the investigation. Award 1 mark for each explanation of strength or limitation, to a maximum of 4 marks. Award a maximum of 1 additional mark for further development of each explanation. Award a maximum of 2 marks if only strengths or limitations are explained. Note: Only about the questionnaire, not about the time or sampling. Possible responses include: Strength: ● One strength of the questionnaire is that it is well-structured and logically organised into two clear sections – demographics as well as perceptions and attitudes – making it easy for respondents to follow and complete. o This reduces the likelihood of confusion or incomplete responses, improving the overall quality of the data collected. 4
OFFICIAL (CLOSED) / NON-SENSITIVE National Junior College 2026 SH2 Preliminary Examinations 8834 Higher 1 Geography Marking Guide Page 7 of 20 Limitation: ● One limitation is that several questions are susceptible to social desirability
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
