SAJC 2026 H1 Geog Prelim Ans
Uploaded by Grassy155 · 16 November 2026
Preview
Text from the first pagesSAJC/8834/01/Prelims/2026 © SAJC 2026 ST ANDREW’S JUNIOR COLLEGE Preliminary Examinations Higher 1 Geography 8834/01 Paper 1 3 hours Additional Materials: Insert SUGGESTED ANSWER SCHEME [Turn over
SAJC/8834/01/Prelims/2026 2 © SAJC 2026 Section A Cluster 2: Fieldwork 1 A group of six junior college students, as part of their school project, wanted to investigate community response to climate change in Singapore. They decided to investigate participation in Singapore's Beverage Container Return Scheme (BCRS). Under the BCRS, consumers pay a 10-cent deposit when purchasing eligible beverages in plastic bottles and metal cans carrying the Deposit Mark. The deposit can be recovered when the empty container is returned to a designated return point. The students investigated the following hypothesis: Convenience has a greater influence than concern about climate change on people's participation in the Beverage Container Return Scheme. They selected three shopping centres in different parts of Singapore, each with a reverse vending machine (RVM). The students divided themselves into three pairs, with one pair at each site. At each site, they: • surveyed 30 people near the RVM using convenience sampling; • used the same questionnaire; • conducted the survey between 12.00 pm and 4.00 pm on one Saturday in August 2026; and • counted the number of people using the RVM during a 30-minute period. At the time of the investigation, the BCRS was still in its transition period. Some beverage containers in circulation did not yet carry the Deposit Mark and could not be returned for the 10-cent refund. Resource 1 shows the locations and characteristics of the three fieldwork sites. Resource 2 shows photographs of examples of reverse vending machines in Singapore. Resource 3 shows the questionnaire used by the students. Resource 4 shows the results of the investigation. (a) Explain one strength and one weakness of the students' hypothesis. [4] AO1 One strength is that the hypothesis is clearly defined and researchable/measurable. It identifies two possible influences on participation, convenience and concern about climate change. These can be measured using the 1 to 5 convenience and climate-concern scales in the questionnaire, while participation can be measured through reported BCRS use and observations of RVM users.
SAJC/8834/01/Prelims/2026 3 © SAJC 2026 One weakness is that the phrase “greater influence” is not sufficiently clearly defined. The investigation can identify whether convenience or climate concern is associated with participation, but the hypothesis does not specify how the relative influence of the two variables will be measured. The fieldwork design therefore cannot easily establish that one variable causes participation more strongly than the other. (b) With reference to Resources 1 and 2, explain the factors that the students should consider when selecting sites to investigate how convenience influences participation in the Beverage Container Return Scheme. [5] AO1 Ensure variation in convenience so that there is a counterfactual. The sites should have contrasting levels of convenience, for example differences in accessibility from the MRT station, location of the RVM within the shopping centre, or ease of reaching the machine. This allows students to compare participation where convenience is relatively high against participation where it is relatively low. Without such variation, they cannot establish whether participation changes with convenience. Keep other factors that could influence participation as similar as possible. The sites should be broadly comparable in characteristics unrelated to convenience so that these do not confound the relationship being investigated. For example, if one RVM has much greater pedestrian footfall than another, it may record more users simply because more people pass it. Differences in shopper profile, RVM functionality or promotional activity could similarly affect participation independently of convenience. Select sites that provide a reasonably representative range of contexts. Resource 1 shows that the three shopping centres are located in different parts of Singapore. Selecting sites from different locations reduces the likelihood that the findings reflect the behaviour of people from only one locality and makes the findings more applicable to BCRS participation in Singapore. (c) Suggest how the students could improve the accuracy and reliability of the data collected on the number of people using the RVMs. [4] AO1 The students should first use a standardised definition of an RVM user, for example counting a person only when they actually deposit at least one eligible container. One student could count using a tally counter while the second student independently checks the count. This reduces missed users or differences in how users are counted, improving accuracy. They should also repeat the 30-minute observations several times at each site, including comparable periods on different days, and calculate a mean number of users. A single 30-minute count could be affected by an unusually busy or quiet period, while repeated measurements would produce more reliable results.
SAJC/8834/01/Prelims/2026 4 © SAJC 2026 (d) With reference to Resource 3, explain the strengths and limitations of the questionnaire used in the investigation. [4] AO2 A strength is that the questionnaire mainly uses closed questions with fixed response options, including 1 to 5 scales for convenience and climate concern. This standardises how respondents answer and reduces differences caused by students recording or interpreting responses differently, therefore increasing the reliability of the data collected. The questionnaire is also short and quick to complete because respondents mostly select from predetermined responses rather than giving lengthy open - ended answers. This makes it easier for the students to survey the required 30 respondents at each site within the limited fieldwork period, reducing the likelihood that the intended sample size cannot be achieved. A limitation is that responses about previous BCRS use and climate concern are self-reported. Respondents may forget how often they have returned containers or may give a higher climate-concern score because they think this is socially desirable. The recorded responses may therefore not reflect their actual behaviour or attitudes, reducing the accuracy of the data. A further limitation is that some fixed response categories may oversimplify respondents' behaviour. For example, asking for the single “main reason” for returning containers forces respondents to select one factor even if convenience, the deposit and environmental concern all influenced their decision. This may produce an inaccurate representation of the factors influencing participation and therefore weaken the validity of conclusions drawn from the questionnaire. (e) Using Resource 4, describe the relationship between mean convenience score and participation in the BCRS at the three sites. [3] AO2 There is a consistent positive relationship between mean convenience score and BCRS participation. Site A has the highest convenience score of 4.4 and also the highest participation, with 73% having used the BCRS at least once and 24 RVM users observed. Site B is intermediate, with a convenience score of 3.2, 50% participation and 13 observed users. Site C has the lowest convenience score of 2.1 and also the lowest participation, at 27% and only six observed users. (f) Evaluate the validity of
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
