TJC 2026 H1 Geog Prelim Ans
Uploaded by Grassy155 · 16 November 2026
Preview
Text from the first pages2026 H1 Geography Preliminary Examination Mark Scheme Section A Fieldwork Question 1 Recycling in Toa Payoh 30 marks 1(a) Explain why the research question is appropriate for this investigation. [3] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each relevant explanation of appropriateness; award further credit for developed reasoning, up to 3. • The question identifies a measurable relationship between accessibility and correct recycling practices in a defined study area. • Walking time and residents’ perceptions may indicate access, while the visual audit provides a measure of correct recycling. The eight sites permit spatial comparison. 1(b) With reference to Resources 2A and 2B, suggest how the students could minimise potential risks during the investigation. [5] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark per relevant risk-minimisation measure; credit resource-linked explanation, up to 5. A risk named without a precaution earns no credit. • Observe the top layer without handling waste; avoid sharp containers and wash or sanitise hands after the audit (Resource 2A). • Work in pairs at the side of the shared walkway and remain alert to pedestrians and cyclists when surveying residents (Resource 2B). • Credit other practical precautions. 1(c) With reference to Resource 3, explain the limitations of the survey questionnaire when used to survey residents during the investigation. [4] Marking guidance: Award up to 2 marks per explained limitation linked to Resource 3, up to 4. • Vague frequency words in Question 1 and estimated walking times in Question 4 may be interpreted or recalled differently. • Question 2 permits only one barrier, while Question 5 combines visibility and accessibility and has an incorrectly numbered response scale. • Self-reported answers may not match actual recycling behaviour. 1(d) Using Resource 4A, describe the extent of correct recycling practices in Toa Payoh. [4] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark per distinct, accurate description using Resource 4A; credit appropriate quantities or proportions, up to 4. • Correct items predominate overall: 101 of 160 visible items, about 63%; they exceed contaminants at six of eight sites. • Practice varies among sites: D has 17 of 20 correct items, while H has 8 of 20. Residential sites generally perform better than market or food sites. 1(e) With reference to Resource 4B, use a suitable data representation technique to show the main barriers to recycling identified by respondents. [4] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark each for a suitable graph with title, appropriately labelled categories or axes and scale, and accurate plotting of all four counts, up to 4. Credit a bar graph or other suitable representation. • The main barriers in Resource 4B are cleaning containers (24), uncertainty about accepted items (21), inconvenient location (17), and other barriers (18 respondents). • Use a zero-based numerical scale and a clear label indicating the number of respondents.
1(f) With reference to all the resources, evaluate the reliability and accuracy of the investigation. [10] Marking guidance: Award holistically up to 10 marks for a balanced evaluation of reliability and accuracy using evidence across the resources. Credit a supported judgement and practical improvements. • Reliability is helped by a common questionnaire, a consistent top-layer audit of 20 items at each of eight sites and the same fieldwork period; one day and limited sites constrain repeatability. • Accuracy is limited by observing only visible items, selecting only the top layer, self-reported survey responses and questionnaire wording. Walking-time estimates may differ from measured accessibility. • Resource 4A suggests site variation in correct disposal; Resource 4B gives residents’ reported access and barriers. Neither alone establishes that accessibility caused observed differences. • Credit repetition at more sites and times, a clearer questionnaire, measured walking times and careful comparison of site and survey results. Section B Sustainable Future and Climate Change Question 2 Urban sustainability 22 marks 2(a) Using Resource 5, describe the global distribution of countries with more than 70% of their urban population living in slums in 2024. [3] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each distinct, accurate description of the global distribution in Resource 5, up to 3. • Countries above 70% are concentrated in sub-Saharan Africa, including parts of West, Central and East Africa. • Few lie outside Africa; Afghanistan is one exception. Such countries are absent from most other world regions shown. 2(b) Explain why slums develop in rapidly urbanising cities. [5] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each relevant reason explained, up to 5. • Rural–urban migration and natural increase may outpace formal housing, infrastructure and job provision. • Low and insecure incomes, expensive land and limited affordable housing push households towards informal settlements. • Weak planning, land tenure and service provision can cause slums to persist. 2(c) Using Resource 6, suggest the possible negative impacts of urban reimaging. [5] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each plausible negative impact suggested from Resource 6; credit a linked explanation, up to 5. • The cartoon shows that only a minority of the new flats are affordable, limiting access for lower-income households. • Reimaging can raise local rents and property values, displacing existing residents and intensifying segregation. • Small living spaces or higher density may affect quality of life and pressure services. 2(d) Using Resource 7, describe the changes in the sustainability of Dundee docks before and after urban reimaging. [5] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each valid before-and-after description related to sustainability, up to 5. Credit cautious inference from Resource 7. • Derelict warehouses in 2006 gave way to cultural and heritage uses, including the museum and the Royal Research Ship Discovery by 2018. • Reuse of docklands may attract visitors and activity, improve the public realm and make more use of former industrial land. • Credit social, economic and environmental dimensions where supported by the images; avoid treating inferred outcomes as directly observed.
2(e) With the use of example(s), explain how and why there might be tension between sustainable urban development and liveability. [4] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each developed explanation of a tension, up to 4. Relevant example(s) are required. • Green or heritage redevelopment may improve environmental quality and attract investment while increasing rents and displacing existing residents. • Compact development or transport restrictions may reduce emissions but create crowding, inconvenience or uneven costs for some groups. Question 3 Climate change 22 marks 3(a) Using Resource 8, describe how atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration has changed over the past 800 000 years. [4] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each distinct and accurate description from Resource 8, up to 4. • CO₂ concentration fluctuated in repeated cycles over most of the last 800 000 years, with earlier peaks generally below about 300 ppm. • The recent increase is steep and exceptional, rising to about 423 ppm in 2024, well above the earlier range. 3(b) Explain how ice and ocean cores provide evidence for past climate variability. [4] Marking guidance: Award 1 mark for each relevant explanation, up to 4. Cover both ice and ocean cores; award at most 3 if only one is addressed. • Datable ice layers and trapped air bubbles reveal past atmospheric composition; oxygen-isotope ratios act as temperature proxies. • Datable ocean sediments and the fossils or isotopes of marine organisms provide evidence of past ocean conditions and climatic change. 3(c) Using Resource 9, compare the sources of greenhouse ga
Content continues in the PDF. Download PDF
